Top Stories
Government: Women under 50 may not need mammograms
7:40 AM on 11/17/2009
The government now says women under 50 who are not high risk don't need mammograms. That's a major change from what experts have said for years to detect breast cancer. Some major medical groups think the government's making a big mistake.
Computer models convinced government experts to change their advice. Those models show getting mammograms too soon may cause more harm than good.
Sabrina Singletary just got a mammogram.
"When I was younger, that's all I kept hearing. That when you turn 40 you know, you should get your mammogram," said Singletary.
But now the government says she doesn't need one. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force women who are not high risk for breast cancer can wait until they're 50 and even then, only need to be screened every other year.
The change comes because they say in younger women, the chance of a bad result outweighs the small benefit.
"That is, the likelihood of having a false positive test with all the attendant anxiety, the additional imaging tests, perhaps even leading to biopsy that may have been unnecessary," said Dr. Diana Petitti of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force.
Major medical groups still recommend mammograms under 50 and worry this new advice may confuse patients.
"The worst outcome for this study would be for women to throw up their arms and say, 'well, I'm not going to get screened at all,'" said the American Cancer Society's Len Lichtenfeld.
They argue the government puts more emphasis on computer models than real patients.
"We're not satisfied at this point that the approach that they used is sufficient and adequate to discard a proven way of saving lives from breast cancer," Lichtenfeld said.
Sabrina Singletary's 41 and says she'll still get a mammogram every year.
But with the government now recommending against it it's unclear if insurance will pay.
The task force also says there's no need to teach women to do self-breast exams.
Follow theGrio on Facebook & Twitter!
Top Stories
-
Essence says rumors of folding are untrue
A recent gawker.com post has the internet abuzz with speculation over whether Essence magazine is in danger of folding...
more
- Presidential disrespect goes prime-time in Obama's Fox interview
- An 'Immortal Life': How one woman's cells helped cure a generation
- Baller-in-chief: Obama's 'March Madness' bracket scores well
- Conservatives use abortion issue to court African-Americans
- Congressional Black Caucus calls current jobs bill 'inadequate'
- Will Michael Jackson's new music be a thriller for fans?
- Could 2010 be the year of the black Republican?
- Five reasons Tiger will come roaring back
- Clarence Thomas' wife's Tea Party ties are supremely disturbing
- It's 'do or die' week for health care reform - how did we get here?
- Democrats' crack-cocaine compromise is still 'racist'
- California police stop proves racial profiling is alive and well
- Slideshow: TV's black child stars - where are they now?
- Todd Bridges buries troubled past in 'Killing Willis'
- Prison shouldn't be a publicity stunt for Lil Wayne
- Oscars' 'Kanye moment' shouldn't overshadow history
- Mo'Nique's win is one of Oscar night's 'Precious' moments
- Lee Daniels: We need to get out of 'Huxtable' mode
- Why African-Americans are more optimistic despite fewer jobs
- Why some people want to make a monkey out of Michelle
- How Obama and Preval can reset US-Haiti relations
- Slideshow: Friends or foes? Where black leaders stand with Obama
- Rangel's loss could be Harlem voters' gain
- Paterson should 'put the people first' and resign
- 'March Madness' isn't amateur, it's big league exploitation
- Torii Hunter is right about blacks in baseball
- Will Roethlisberger get the Michael Vick treatment?
- An NFL without a salary cap could make fans the biggest losers
- Barbershop Buzz on sex addiction: Is it a myth or malady?
- Tiger's been tamed, now leave him alone
- Selma, a town rich with history, seeks new legacy
- Slideshow: A glimpse of Hawaii's gorgeous landscape
- How to celebrate Black History Month in the Big Apple
- Slideshow: Vancouver's Commercial Drive captures city's diversity
- Five things you didn't know about Kwanzaa (but should)
- Africans find unlikely education at Ukraine universities
- Too many Tigers, not enough Trojans
- How black women can combat genital herpes crisis
- New studies reveal the urgency of first lady's obesity fight
- CDC enlists celebs to launch social media fight against HIV/AIDS
- Obama's health care reform efforts stymied by politics of prejudice
- Obama's last stand on health care reform
- Made in America: Black-owned businesses blaze trails on our soil
- Is the average single black woman really worth just $5?
- Three reasons why Obama should take small steps to save jobs
- 2/22/10 - theGrio & CNBC Market Update
- 'We Are the World' turns 25: Can a remake resuscitate Haiti?
- Does race play a role in the way we tip?
- Ugandan children capture their own stories with Project Focus
- Barbershop Buzz: Which women inspire you?
- NYC b-boys hope to be discovered dancing on subways
- TheGrio's 100: Tim King, prepping the next generation
- Rev. Frederick D. Reese remembers 'Bloody Sunday' in Selma
- TheGrio's 100: Kamala Harris, the future of California politics
- 'Brooklyn's Finest' is flawed but fiercely entertaining
- Why audiences should opt-out of 'Cop Out'
- Black music without borders: Five artists you need to hear
- 'Ameriville': Stories of Hurricane Katrina still alive onstage
- Sade's return is worth the wait
- 'The Book of Eli': A not-so-new parable of burnt-out beauty
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Myspace
Flickr
Podcast
Wordpress
Linkedin
Last.fm
Tumblr
Identi.ca
Plurk