Alicia Keys' new album proves to be under par

On Alicia Keys' previous CDs, the gifted singer-songwriter-pianist presented songs that were epic and impeccable -- more so than her actual albums. Tunes like "Fallin'," ''If I Ain't Got You" and "Like You'll Never See Me Again" are timeless grooves that helped make the R&B singer a global, Grammy superstar.

What's unfortunate is that "The Element of Freedom", Keys' fourth studio release, does not have a jam as outstanding as her past hits. Most of the songs are mediocre, like the first single, the empty-sounding "Doesn't Mean Anything." Even her duet with Beyonce on the Swizz Beatz "Put It In a Love Song," is a disappointment -- it's an amateurish dance tune on which the guest overpowers the main star.

Perhaps the best thing you can say about "Freedom" is that the songs mesh well, and create a smooth sound, albeit weak one.

Of course, Keys' soaring voice always shines, even on so-so songs. It especially stands out on the yearning "Un-thinkable (I'm Ready)," the gloomy but groovy opening track, "Love Is Blind" and "Try Sleeping With a Broken Heart," an elevated drum-filled pop ballad that showcases the singer's versatility.

Keys, who isn't known for collaborating with many artists on her own CDs, enlists music's most anticipated singer-rapper, Drake, on "Un-thinkable (I'm Ready)." The newcomer takes a back seat to Keys by singing background vocals. She takes you on a lovely, magic carpet ride on this "ready for love" tune.

Copyright 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.