OpiniontheGrio Exclusive
GOP can't turn a blind eye to bigots in their midst
|
7:48 PM on 03/25/2010 |
| Join Our Mailing List |
Opponents of the health care reform bill carry a "Kill the Bill" sign as protesters begin to arrive at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Sunday, March 21, 2010. House Democratic leaders predicted Sunday the final tally on President Barack Obama's historic health care bill will meet or exceed the 216 votes required for passage. (AP Photo/Charles Dharapak)
It has only been two short days and I have already been called on by MSNBC's Countdown to once again discuss the issue of rising rancor in American political discourse in the wake of the health care reform debate. I have another opportunity to expand on those ideas here on theGrio.
Throughout the country, Democratic members of Congress have been receiving aggressive messages and, in some cases, death threats based on their vote for health care reform.
On Thursday night Lawrence O'Donnell asked me "Do these threats threaten the democratic process?"
WATCH THE VIDEO OF MY APPEARANCE ON 'COUNTDOWN' HERE:Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
When it comes to democracy I firmly believe that ideas are not dangerous. The attempt to limit ideas or to shame or punish people for having ideas is far more dangerous. I work as a professor and I am committed to a fundamental belief that the free exchange of ideas is the basis of a healthy, functioning democracy.
One of the most important classes of ideas that any democracy must protect is the right to disagree with the government. Remember that Thomas Jefferson wrote in Declaration of Independence that:
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. -- That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,"
This was an amazing and novel idea! The idea that governments should derive their authority from the consent of the governed, rather than from the Divine Right of Kings, changed the world forever. Our elections are the primary tools through which we give and retract consent, but we also have the right to march, to yell, to write letters, and to run for office ourselves. As citizens of a democracy we are not just the ruled, we are the rulers.
But we must also remember that Jefferson wrote
"Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes"
We have a right to express our ideas. We have a right to organize to criticize the government when we disagree with its policies. However, with rights come responsibilities. Those who are behaving violently because they disagree with a policy that was publicly debated and duly passed by a majority of rightfully elected representatives have abdicated their basic responsibility to democracy.
Our founders modeled for us the way that responsible, reasoned disagreement should take place in the public square. Yes, they were often rowdy and irreverent, but they also gave us the carefully crafted arguments found in the Federalist Papers, not just the empty rhetoric of dissent.
In fact here is my assignment, let's all go back and read the Federalist Papers as a model of disagreement.
Now is the time for Republican leadership to exercise the responsibilities of leadership. For decades they have claimed to be the champions of personal responsibility. Now is the time for collective responsibility. The violence, the threats, the danger are emerging from a wing of their party. They need to actively work to stem the tide of potentially dangerous actions. They should not stop dissenting, but they must vigorously and repeatedly denounce acts and threats of bigotry and violence.
Democratic Party leadership must continue to welcome debate, discussion and dissent. It is the basis of healthy democracy. But GOP leadership cannot simply pretend that the vitriol being expressed in communities across the country is unrelated to their actions on Capitol Hill.
Follow theGrio on Facebook & Twitter!
-
Women's shaved hair revolution taking shape
-
Rap Genius: The top 5 rap lyrics of the week -- Pusha T talks money
-
New MLK assassination footage revealed in Smithsonian Channel doc
-
Komen won't cut breast-screening grants to Planned Parenthood
-
NBA All-Star roster revealed: From Kobe to Chris Paul, LA teams dominate
-
The 10 most memorable presidential campaign themes (SLIDESHOW)
-
Angelo Dundee dead: Legendary trainer for Muhammad Ali, Sugar Ray Leonard dies at 90
-
Black stars shine at 2012 SAG Awards (SLIDESHOW)
-
'Key & Peele' set to kick off: What are the best Obama parodies?
-
Anthony Mackie in 'Man on a Ledge': Is he the next Denzel? (SLIDESHOW)
-
Black unemployment: What Washington can do now to address the high black jobless rate
-
The trouble with Trump's Romney endorsement: It's the birtherism, stupid
-
Eddie Long 'crowning': Why do black churches often put pastors on a pedestal?
-
Why Jan Brewer's disrespect will motivate black voters for Obama
-
Trump endorsement may hurt, not help Romney
Popular Topics
- Barack Obama: 1767 Stories
- Music: 746 Stories
- Hip Hop: 622 Stories
- Basketball: 449 Stories
- Economy: 438 Stories
- Football: 428 Stories
- Congress: 426 Stories
- NFL: 424 Stories
- NBA: 406 Stories
- Unemployment: 404 Stories
- Haiti: 394 Stories
- Film: 378 Stories
- New York: 377 Stories
- Election2012: 368 Stories
- Michael Jackson: 358 Stories
- Michelle Obama: 357 Stories
- Republicans: 356 Stories
- Murder: 348 Stories
- Democrats: 334 Stories
- Education: 304 Stories



COMMENT NOW
print