Opinion
Abortion as population control?
|
7:34 AM on 07/16/2009 |
| Join Our Mailing List |
(AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)
African Americans who are just as suspicious of white liberals as they are of conservatives will have plenty of fodder this week as recent comments by left-leaning Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bater Ginsberg have many asking for an explanation.
In a recent interview with the New York Times magazine, Gingsburg was asked to elaborate on an earlier answer regarding poor women and their access to reproductive clinics. In response the Justice is quoted as saying: "Frankly I had thought that at the time Roe was decided, there was concern about population growth and particularly growth in populations that we don't want to have too many of."
As it is stated, Ginsberg appears either to admit that she was part of the "we" that had concerns about population growth in "unwanted" populations, or that in her view the members of the Court who decided Roe vs. Wade had those concerns at the time.
Either stance should disturb us greatly and is of particular interest at a time when Sonia Sotomayor is undergoing congressional hearings and facing questions about abortion. Is Justice Ginsburg advocating abortion as a means of population control?
The fact that eugenics and reproductive rights have always had an intertwined, if not mutualistic, relationship has been all but forgotten in our collective discussions about the African American experience. Ginsberg has reminded us of this, regrettably conjuring up recollections of buried national embarrassments like the infamous Tuskegee Experiment or President Richard Nixon's insistence that abortion was necessary in the case of interracial babies.
Justice Ginsburg deserves to explain her comments. She does not get a pass because she supports affirmative action nor should we assume she is a racist because she had a moment of distasteful inarticulateness.
As an intellectually curious and fair-minded black body politic, we should hold Justice Gingsberg to account. So please explain your comment Justice Ginsberg. We eagerly await your answer.
Follow theGrio on Facebook & Twitter!
-
Women's shaved hair revolution taking shape
-
Rap Genius: The top 5 rap lyrics of the week -- Pusha T talks money
-
New MLK assassination footage revealed in Smithsonian Channel doc
-
Komen won't cut breast-screening grants to Planned Parenthood
-
NBA All-Star roster revealed: From Kobe to Chris Paul, LA teams dominate
-
The 10 most memorable presidential campaign themes (SLIDESHOW)
-
Angelo Dundee dead: Legendary trainer for Muhammad Ali, Sugar Ray Leonard dies at 90
-
Black stars shine at 2012 SAG Awards (SLIDESHOW)
-
'Key & Peele' set to kick off: What are the best Obama parodies?
-
Anthony Mackie in 'Man on a Ledge': Is he the next Denzel? (SLIDESHOW)
-
Black unemployment: What Washington can do now to address the high black jobless rate
-
The trouble with Trump's Romney endorsement: It's the birtherism, stupid
-
Eddie Long 'crowning': Why do black churches often put pastors on a pedestal?
-
Why Jan Brewer's disrespect will motivate black voters for Obama
-
Trump endorsement may hurt, not help Romney
Popular Topics
- Barack Obama: 1767 Stories
- Music: 746 Stories
- Hip Hop: 622 Stories
- Basketball: 449 Stories
- Economy: 438 Stories
- Football: 428 Stories
- Congress: 426 Stories
- NFL: 424 Stories
- NBA: 406 Stories
- Unemployment: 404 Stories
- Haiti: 394 Stories
- Film: 378 Stories
- New York: 377 Stories
- Election2012: 368 Stories
- Michael Jackson: 358 Stories
- Michelle Obama: 357 Stories
- Republicans: 356 Stories
- Murder: 348 Stories
- Democrats: 334 Stories
- Education: 304 Stories



COMMENT NOW
print