Opinion
'The Princess and the Frog' avoids the elephant in the room
9:41 AM on 11/27/2009
"The Princess and the Frog." (AP Photo/Disney)
Disney's latest animated feature "The Princess and the Frog" is a milestone of sorts, offering a return to the company's decades long tradition of hand-drawn animation while also featuring the franchise's first African-American animated princess, a young woman of modest means named Tiana.
The studio is essentially playing catch up to other parts of the media landscape and the world. A brown heroine or hero with a powerful myth could have been presented long ago considering the abundance of Diaspora stories in plain sight. So it's with ambivalence and a sense of muted celebration that I say the kid-friendly film can be enjoyed for what it is - an entertaining, beautifully illustrated narrative with doses of brown nobility, ho-hum sentimentality, historical inaccuracy and some ideas that subvert the genre.
Tiana, voiced and fantastically sung by Dreamgirl Anika Noni Rose, is a workaholic waitress in what seems to be early 20th century New Orleans. Our heroine is saving dough so she can open up her own restaurant, following her father's dreams. Her path ends up crossing with womanizer Prince Naveen of Maldonia (Bruno Campos), who's been turned into a frog by the sorcerer Doctor Facilier (Keith David). Tiana kisses the amphibian in hopes of reversing the spell and thereby getting money from his inheritance for her eatery, but instead gets zapped into toad-ville as well since she wasn't born into royalty. And the games begin.
Some of the common Disney cartoon tropes remain - singing animals, pristine parental figures, an effete male villain, blind magical thinking - even as the film plays with some common traditions. Tiana could care less about being completed by a man, and in fact needs to be reminded to make room for relaxation and romance. And there's an interesting melding of traditions. In one scene, bayou priestess Mama Odie (Jenifer Lewis) is backed by a gospel choir while singing, "you gotta dig a little deeper." Christianity and voodoo are bedfellows here, and I suspect most moviegoers won't bat an eye at the juxtaposition.
WATCH NIGHTLY NEWS' REPORT ON DISNEY'S BLACK PRINCESSVisit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy
As for race, however, there's no direct acknowledgment of the dehumanizing prejudice people of African descent would've faced at the time. In this universe, Naveen and his brownness is seen as perfectly suitable husband material for spoiled blonde debutante Charlotte (Jennifer Cody) and her sweepingly friendly, open-minded Big Daddy (John Goodman).
White old-school Southerners get off easy for sure, yet this isn't necessarily something to take personally; Disney has rarely been known to meaningfully tackle ugly issues in its animated films, and one would need to wish on many a star for an exception to be made in the name of skin color.
If there's anything that warrants attention, it's that other elephant in the room: class. The film has a paradoxical relationship to status, upholding the glory of royalty and riches for some even as certain characters illustrate the perils of being consumed by money. A sense of uneasiness creeps into some scenes when one sees how self-absorbed Charlotte and Big Daddy have been with their wealth as Tiana and her family work painstakingly hard to creep ahead.
Yet there's hope in the love story. A step away from Cinderella traditions, this film has the privileged would-be monarch being transformed by his association with a commoner. He finds happiness in her world. They have their expected happily ever after, yet nonetheless, something different is being said to girls and boys of all ages and all colors.
Follow theGrio on Facebook & Twitter!
Top Stories
-
Dems down to the wire lobbying for reform votes
VIDEO - They've made some progress. A fourth Democrat, John Boccieri of Ohio, has switched his vote from "no" to "yes."...
more
- Clarence Thomas' wife's Tea Party ties are supremely disturbing
- Democrats' crack-cocaine compromise is still 'racist'
- How 'Bloody Sunday' changed America
- Three reasons why Obama should take small steps to save jobs
- Why audiences should opt-out of 'Cop Out'
- Van Jones returns: 'I'm more committed to the politics of hope now'
- Todd Bridges buries troubled past in 'Killing Willis'
- Lee Daniels: We need to get out of 'Huxtable' mode
- Slideshow: 20 films that uplifted black America
- Slideshow: 15 films that hurt black America
- 'High School Musical' star Corbin Bleu talks to theGrio about new Broadway role
- Slideshow: The 25 most influential albums by African-Americans
- Obama proposes $900 million in grants to stop school drop outs
- Charles Rangel should resign in light of ethics panel ruling
- Obama, Republicans clash at heated health summit
- Fox News contributor Angela McGlowan to run for Congress in Mississippi
- NY Gov. Paterson has mere $620G to battle $12 million-man Andrew Cuomo
- The new Obama is the old Obama
- AP sources: Woods likely to return at Masters
- Michael Jordan to buy NBA's Bobcats
- First black figure skating pair leaps over color barriers & national borders
- Slideshow: The 15 best dunkers in NBA history
- Where's the diversity at the Winter Olympics?
- Slideshow: African-Americans at the Winter games
- Certain carnival dances said to come from the days of slavery
- Selma, a town rich with history, seeks new legacy
- 'Black Ski' gets a lift from the First Family
- Slideshow: A glimpse of Hawaii's gorgeous landscape
- How to celebrate Black History Month in the Big Apple
- Afro-centric brides on parade
- TheGrio's 100: Mary Spio, reaching beyond the stars
- TheGrio's 100: Tim King, prepping the next generation
- TheGrio's 100: Kamala Harris, the future of California politics
- TheGrio Reflects: The genius of Ray Charles
- TheGrio's 100: Dr. Kathie-Ann Joseph, battling breast cancer and more
- TheGrio's 100: Clarence Otis Jr, serving 400 million meals a year
- TheGrio Reflects: Malcolm X rails against complacent civil rights activists
- TheGrio Reflects: Aretha Franklin, the Queen of Soul
- TheGrio Reflects: Muhammad Ali on Vietnam
- theGrio Reflects: The Story Of Emmett Till
- theGrio Reflects: the Underground Railroad
- theGrio Reflects: The 14th Amendment is adopted
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Myspace
Flickr
Podcast
Wordpress
Linkedin
Last.fm
Tumblr
Identi.ca
Plurk